DEFENSE HANDBOOK · COLORADO · CHAPTER 09

Defense Experts, Rule 35 & C.R.E. 702

Retain experts to answer defined questions, keep opinions within discipline, and build the foundation before admissibility is challenged.

Select the disputed proposition first, the discipline second, and the expert third.

9.1 Apply the Expert-Need Test

Ask which proposition requires specialized knowledge, why the jury cannot reliably decide it unaided, which discipline fits the proposition, and what changes if the opinion is accepted. Not every disagreement needs a testifying expert, and not every consultant who educates counsel should testify.

9.2 Classify Retained, Treating, and Consulting Experts

Retained testifying experts have detailed Rule 26(a)(2) disclosure obligations. Treating professionals may offer expert opinions and must be adequately disclosed. Consulting experts not expected to testify ordinarily receive stronger work-product protection.

9.3 Use Rule 35 as a Focused Examination

Identify the condition in controversy, why existing material is insufficient, examiner qualifications, scope, testing, duration, location, and requested conditions. Schedule the examination well before the expert deadline because examiner availability and report preparation can become critical-path items.

9.4 Build an Expert File That Can Survive Cross-Examination

Provide a curated but complete record, including unfavorable material. For every opinion record the conclusion, basis, method, assumptions, alternatives considered, and limitations. The report should be defensible to opposing counsel, understandable to the judge, and teachable to the jury.

9.5 Apply C.R.E. 702 / Shreck Opinion by Opinion

Colorado’s Shreck framework examines qualification, reliability, usefulness or fit, and C.R.E. 403. Challenge the opinion rather than merely attacking the witness as a whole. Experience does not repair an unsupported analytical bridge.

9.6 Police Discipline Boundaries

Medical causation, biomechanics, reconstruction, psychology, digital forensics, vocational issues, and economics are different disciplines. Disclosures should explain exactly where an expert’s permitted opinion ends and another discipline begins.

9.7 Disclose Technical Limitations as Well as Conclusions

A technical expert should identify both what the data supports and what it cannot establish. That distinction is especially important with carrier or device metadata, where authentication of records and interpretation of user activity are different questions.

Disputed Proposition → Expert-Need Test → Discipline → Expert → Record/Rule 35 → Disclosure → Deposition → 702 Gatekeeping → Trial Scope

Defense Objective

Use specialized testimony only where it answers a defined disputed proposition and survives Colorado gatekeeping.

Evidence Needed

Complete source record, Rule 35 materials where used, expert CV/qualifications, methods, assumptions, alternative explanations, report, deposition, and supplements.

Deadline / Trigger

Backward-plan retention, examination, disclosure, deposition, and 702 briefing from the CMO and trial date.

Waiver / Failure Trap

Retaining an expert merely because the case reached an “expert phase”; incomplete files; opinions beyond discipline; material opinion changes without supplementation.

Defense Checklist
  • Define expert question before retention.
  • Decide separately on Rule 35.
  • Send complete curated record.
  • QC qualification/method/assumptions/limitations.
  • Track supplementation.
  • Depose opposing experts after full disclosure.
  • Build 702 challenge opinion by opinion.
  • Convert surviving opinions into trial testimony and valuation.
Record to Carry Forward

An opinion matrix showing each expert proposition, foundation, methodology, assumption, limitation, admissibility status, and trial use.

  • C.R.C.P. 26(a)(2), 26(b)(4), 35 — expert disclosures/discovery and physical/mental examinations.
  • C.R.E. 702 — admissibility of expert testimony.
  • People v. Shreck, 22 P.3d 68 (Colo. 2001) — Colorado reliability/qualification/usefulness/403 gatekeeping framework.
  • Estate of Ford v. Eicher, 250 P.3d 262 (Colo. 2011) — expert qualification and admissibility principles.
  • People v. Ramirez, 155 P.3d 371 (Colo. 2007) — reliability and analytically sound basis.
  • People v. Martinez, 2024 CO 69 — no formal ritual of tendering/accepting a witness as an expert is required under C.R.E. 702.

Currentness rule: Verify the current official rule, statute, jury instruction, appellate history, entered order, and assigned judge’s practice standards before use.