LITIGATION · COLORADO · COVERAGE & DEFENSE

Reservation of Rights & Duty to Defend

A liability insurer may defend a suit while preserving specified coverage positions. In Colorado, the defense obligation, indemnity obligation, insurer control rights, and defense counsel’s duties must be analyzed separately.

Four Questions Must Be Kept Separate

  1. Duty to defend. Does the liability policy require the insurer to provide or fund a defense against the claim?
  2. Control of the defense. Who has contractual authority over defense and settlement decisions while the insurer is performing that duty?
  3. Duty to indemnify. Must the insurer ultimately pay a covered settlement or judgment?
  4. Defense counsel’s professional duties. What duties does the lawyer retained and paid by the insurer owe to the insured client?

Colorado authority treats these as related but distinct questions.

Colorado’s Broad Duty-to-Defend Framework

Hecla Mining Co. v. New Hampshire Insurance Co., 811 P.2d 1083 (Colo. 1991), remains a foundational Colorado duty-to-defend authority. When the insurer doubts coverage but the claim potentially triggers a defense, Colorado authority recognizes defense under a reservation of rights as an appropriate course rather than assuming the insurer must simply refuse the defense.

In Auto-Owners Insurance Co. v. Bolt Factory Lofts Owners Association, 2021 CO 32, the Colorado Supreme Court reaffirmed that an insurer’s reservation of rights does not, standing alone, eliminate the insurer’s contractual control of the liability defense. The court relied on Hecla, Farmers Group, Inc. v. Trimble, 691 P.2d 1138 (Colo. 1984), and Nunn v. Mid-Century Insurance Co., 244 P.3d 116 (Colo. 2010).

Official Colorado Supreme Court opinion — Auto-Owners v. Bolt Factory (2021 CO 32)

What a Reservation of Rights Does

A reservation-of-rights letter ordinarily allows the insurer to perform the defense while preserving specified policy defenses or indemnity positions. It should therefore be read issue by issue:

  • Which claim, person, act, exclusion, condition or damage category is reserved?
  • What policy language is invoked?
  • What facts does the insurer say may determine coverage?
  • Is the reservation directed to indemnity, defense costs, both, or another contractual issue?
  • What practical exposure could remain with the insured if the insurer later prevails?

Reservation Does Not Automatically Equal Independent Defense Control

Colorado is important here. The Supreme Court rejected the proposition that an insurer automatically loses its right to control the defense merely because it is defending under a reservation of rights. Bolt Factory explains that a reservation alone is insufficient to trigger the protective circumstances addressed in Nunn; refusal to defend or an unreasonable refusal to settle within limits can present materially different circumstances.

The Insured Is Defense Counsel’s Client

Colorado Bar Association Formal Ethics Opinion 91 states that insurer-selected defense counsel owes undivided fidelity to the insured and, for purposes of the opinion, does not thereby create an attorney-client relationship with the carrier. The opinion is advisory, not binding on the Colorado Supreme Court or attorney-discipline authorities.

Colorado Rules of Professional Conduct governing communication, conflicts, third-party payment, confidentiality, aggregate settlements and professional independence remain central. In particular, Rule 1.8(f) addresses third-party payment and Rule 5.4(c) prohibits a person paying a lawyer from directing or regulating the lawyer’s professional judgment.

Colorado Bar Association — Formal Ethics Opinions

Conflict Audit

A reservation of rights should trigger a disciplined conflict analysis, not an automatic conclusion that appointed counsel must withdraw.

  • Could facts developed to defend liability also determine noncoverage?
  • Could one proposed factual position materially benefit the carrier while harming the insured?
  • Could the verdict exceed available indemnity limits?
  • Are exemplary damages or other claims potentially outside indemnity?
  • Is defense counsel being asked to take or avoid action because of carrier interests rather than the insured’s defense?
  • Does the insured need separate coverage counsel to advise about who ultimately bears a particular exposure?

Excess Exposure and the Nunn Framework

Nunn v. Mid-Century Insurance Co., 244 P.3d 116 (Colo. 2010), addresses an insured’s protection when an insurer’s allegedly unreasonable settlement conduct exposes the insured to a judgment above policy limits. Bolt Factory confirms that a reservation of rights by itself is not the same thing as the refusal-to-defend or failure-to-settle circumstances that can permit additional protective action by the insured.

Official Colorado Supreme Court opinion — Nunn v. Mid-Century

What the Crash Victim Should Understand

The fact that an insurer is providing a lawyer does not prove that every claimed loss will be indemnified, that all available policies have been identified, or that every insured has the same coverage. Claimants should verify coverage through applicable disclosure law, discovery, and source documents rather than infer coverage from the appearance of defense counsel.

Primary Authorities

Legal review: October 3, 2026. Educational information; the policy language and current primary authority govern a specific case.