LITIGATION · COLORADO · PRE-SUIT RESOLUTION

Pre-Suit Settlement & Demand Practice

Most crash claims begin outside court. A disciplined pre-suit process identifies responsibility, coverage, proof, damages, deadlines, reimbursement interests and release consequences before deciding whether litigation is necessary.

The Pre-Suit Sequence

Preserve → Identify Parties → Verify Coverage → Build Medical & Economic Proof → Evaluate Liability → Identify Liens / Benefits → Make or Evaluate Demand → Negotiate → Document Settlement or File Suit.

1. Build the Record Before the Demand

  • Crash report, photographs, video, witnesses, vehicles and digital evidence.
  • Medical chronology tied to source records rather than a bill total alone.
  • Past and future economic-loss support.
  • Prior conditions and later events identified honestly.
  • Primary, umbrella/excess, commercial, employer or other potentially applicable coverage.
  • Medicare, Medicaid, health-plan, workers’ compensation or provider reimbursement issues that can affect net recovery.

2. A Demand Is a Decision Document

A useful demand identifies the responsible parties, evidence, injuries and damages actually claimed, known coverage, requested resolution, material conditions and expiration. It should distinguish established facts from medical, economic or legal conclusions still subject to proof.

3. Time-Limited Demands

A time-limited demand can affect both the insurer and its insured when potential exposure exceeds available limits. There is no substitute for reading the actual proposal: amount, deadline, claimants, persons to be released, claims to be released, payment mechanics, liens, confidentiality and other material conditions all matter.

Do not confuse a pre-suit demand with a statutory offer of settlement under C.R.S. § 13-17-202. The latter is a litigation cost-shifting mechanism governed by its own statutory requirements.

4. The Insured Driver Has a Separate Stake

When a claim may exceed limits or includes potentially uncovered exposure, the insured has a personal interest in material settlement opportunities. Defense counsel’s communication duties and the carrier’s settlement obligations should not be reduced to an internal adjuster-authorization process.

5. Before Signing a Release

  • Confirm every releasing and released person or entity.
  • Identify unresolved property, bodily injury, consortium, UM/UIM or other claims.
  • Resolve or account for liens and reimbursement rights.
  • Understand confidentiality, indemnity and hold-harmless language.
  • Verify payment timing and dismissal mechanics.
  • Do not assume payment of one policy limit releases every possible responsible party or coverage layer.

Colorado Authority Desk

  • Nunn v. Mid-Century Insurance Co., 244 P.3d 116 (Colo. 2010) — excess-judgment / insurer-settlement framework.
  • C.R.S. § 10-3-1117 — automobile liability policy-information disclosure; use the current 2026 statutory text.
  • C.R.S. § 13-17-202 — statutory offers of settlement after suit; distinct from ordinary pre-suit demands.
  • Colo. RPC 1.4 and 1.8(g) where lawyer communication or aggregate settlements are implicated.

2026 Colorado Revised Statutes — official title downloads

Reviewed: October 3, 2026. A particular demand must be evaluated under its actual terms and current law.

Related Guides